Personal tools

Talk:Main Page

From GPLv3 Wiki

(Difference between revisions)
Revision as of 22:24, 1 March 2006
johns (Talk | contribs)
A place for external links? (updated)
← Previous diff
Revision as of 02:39, 27 March 2006
dede (Talk | contribs)

Next diff →
Line 1: Line 1:
-== Discussion Draft Views ==+two thumbs up!!!Oh, there is such a thing ! It is really too interesting. Heartily! I come to USA, welcome to come to USA to play, I will become your guide then
- +[http://www.dshow.com.cn 杭州网站建设] [http://www.dshow.com.cn 杭州网络公司] [http://www.cato.co.jp/sony_vaio/ sony vaio] [http://www.cato.co.jp/sony-style/ sonystyle] [http://denwa.omiki.com/ 国際電話のかけ方] [http://expenses.ashigaru.jp/ 学資保険] [http://www.cato.co.jp/sonyvaio/ ソニー バイオ] [http://www.cato.co.jp/pc/ パソコン] [http://www.cato.co.jp/sony_style/ ソニースタイル] [http://www.wowgoldvip.com/Cheap-wow-gold.asp cheap wow gold] [http://www.stonephenix.com/products/other-designs.htm Marble fireplace surround] [http://www.stonephenix.com/products/marblesculpture/statue.htm Marble statue] [http://www.stonephenix.com/products/bathtub2.htm Marble bathtub] [http://www.stonephenix.com/products/animal.htm Marble lions] [http://www.stonephenix.com/optioncolors.htm Sandstone tile] [http://www.stonephenix.com/products/basin.htm Marble doorway ] [http://www.stonephenix.com/optioncolorl.htm Blue limestone tile ] [http://www.stonephenix.com/products/gazebo.htm Marble gazebo ] [http://www.stonephenix.com/products/marble-pillar.htm Marble pillar] [http://www.wowgoldvip.com/Cheap-world-of-warcraft-gold.asp Cheap world of warcraft gold ] [http://www.replica-watch-center.com/ replica watch] [http://www.replicashopping.com/ replica watch] [http://www.replica-watch-center.com/html/Rolex_Ladys_2.html replica watch] [http://www.replicashopping.com/html/replica-Other-Watches_rolex-replica-9_Ot1.html replica watch] [http://www.replica-watch-center.com/html/Rolex_Ladys_6.html replica rolex] [http://www.replicashopping.com/html/replica-Rolex-Watches_rolex-replica-1_Ro1.html replica rolex] [http://www.game-level.com/powerleveling1.html Powerleveling] [http://www.game-level.com/power-leveling.html power leveling] [http://www.game-level.com/wow-powerleveling.html wow powerleveling] [http://www.game-level.com/wow-power-leveling.html wow power leveling] [http://www.game-level.com/World-Of-Warcraft-powerleveling.html World Of Warcraft powerleveling] [http://www.game-level.com World Of Warcraft powerleveling] [http://www.game-level.com/world-of-warcraft-power-leveling.html world of warcraft power leveling] [http://www.evergreen-aloe.cn/htm/e2-1-0.php aloe vera] [http://www.evergreen-aloe.cn/ aloe vera] [http://www.wowgoldvip.com/ Buy World of Warcraft gold] [http://www.wowgoldvip.com/ Buy WoW gold] [http://www.wowgoldvip.com/news_list.asp Buy WoW gold] [http://www.wowgoldvip.com/news_list1.asp Buy World of Warcraft gold ] [http://www.stonephenix.com/products/marble_fireplace.htm Marble fireplace] [http://www.stonephenix.com/products/column_pedestal.htm Marble columns] [http://www.stonephenix.com/products/stone_fountain.htm Marble fountain] [http://www.stonephenix.com/products/marble_sculpture.htm Marble sculpture] [http://www.stonephenix.com Marble sculpture] [http://www.zjunited.com/english/kongzhi_3.asp IRON OXIDE] [http://www.zjunited.com/english/about_2.asp IRON OXIDE] [http://www.lykwell.com paper box made in china] [http://www.lykwell.com/indexcopy.htm china paper bag] [http://www.bj-huayang.com/product_pvc_English.html antistatic] [http://www.lykwell.com china paper box ] [http://www.stonephenix.com/products/table_bench.htm Marble bench] [http://www.stonephenix.com/products/bathtub.htm Stone bathtub] [http://www.stonephenix.com/products/flowerpot.htm Stone flowerpot] [http://www.stonephenix.com/products/Carved_fireplace.htm Carved fireplace] [http://www.cnjunhe.com/ rubber hose] [http://www.cn-frp.com/jinguang/3/1/t2_1.htm frp pipe,FRP RO Pressure Vessels ] [http://www.cn-frp.com/jinguang/en.htm magnesium oxide board] [http://www.cn-frp.com/jinguang/3/1/t3_1.htm PULTRUDED PROFILES] [http://www.wlchem.com/ sodium percarbonate] [http://www.hailide.com.cn/indexe.asp Flex banner] [http://www.hailide.com.cn/eBusiness/en/index.asp Industrial polyester yarn] [http://www.bamboo-veneer.net/product.htm bamboo veneer] [http://www.bamboo-veneer.net/ bamboo veneer] [http://www.yn578.com/ 云南旅游 ] [http://www.ynkmty.com 云南旅游] [http://www.ynkmty.com/ShowWeb.asp?ClassID=100 云南旅游] [http://www.yn578.com/rout_list2.php?routtype=27 云南旅游] [http://www.cnsunway.com/touzi.html 投资] [http://www.cnsunway.com/chuangye.html 创业] [http://jewelry5.net/ 银饰批发] [http://www.chasedream.com mba] [http://www.365igo.cn 家居用品] [http://www.zdfzx.com/rfzx.asp 隆胸] [http://www.365igo.cn/365igoweb/1CAB1C9D0CACEC6B7/50301/1/0/1.htm 饰品|925银饰] [http://www.365igo.cn/365igoweb/1BCD2BED3D3C3C6B7/50301/1/0/1.htm 家居用品] [http://www.365igo.cn/silver.htm 银饰] [http://www.365igo.cn 饰品] [http://www.shmenjin.com 门禁] [http://www.shjiankong.com 监控] [http://www.bjyhtf.com 翻译公司]|翻译公司| [http://www.e-fanyi.com.cn/ 翻译公司 |翻译公司]| [http://www.zjunited.com/about_2.asp 颜料] [http://www.8009999008.com 花店] [http://www.jwac.net/main.asp 中央空调] [http://www.8009999008.com 深圳鲜花] [http://www.lipin258.com 礼品] [http://www.lipin258.com 礼品公司] [http://www.dshow.com.cn 杭州网站建设] [http://www.tuiguang.org/fygs/ 翻译公司] [http://www.zuche258.com/zc/ 租车] [http://www.zuche258.com/zc/ 上海租车] [http://www.zuche258.com/ 上海租车|汽车租赁] [http://www.zuche258.com/qczl/ 汽车租赁|上海汽车租赁] [http://www.xinyitong.net 英语翻译] [http://www.jipiao258.com 机票|] [http://www.51ebiz.net/webset.htm 上海网站建设] [http://www.xylww.com/ 毕业论文] [http://www.cato.co.jp/sonyvaio/ ソニー バイオ] [http://www.cato.co.jp/pc/ パソコン] [http://www.cato.co.jp/sony_style/ ソニースタイル] [http://denwa.omiki.com/ 国際電話のかけ方] [http://www.guanfiu.jp/pro3.htm ウォータースポーツ用品] [http://www.guanfiu.jp/pro1.htm エアーベッド] [http://www.guanfiu.jp/pro0.htm エアーベッド]
-This page is the designated catch-all for random questions -- and there's no place that I can easily find for general questions and comments about the process, rather than about the draft.+
- +
-I think it would be very helpful to the users not only to have a discussion draft online, and a comment-annotated draft, both of which are there, but perhaps a diff-style view between GPLv2 and the current draft of GPLv3. This would allow people to easily browse and see what the differences are.+
- +
-:The [http://gplv3.fsf.org/rationale rationale document] serves much of this purpose. It explains what changes have been made, and why they have been put in place. An [http://www.simnet.is/velfag/tmp/gpl2gpl3diff.html unofficial, more traditional diff] is also available. --[[User:brett|brett]] 14:25, 17 January 2006 (EST)+
- +
-== Newly compatible licences ==+
- +
-There should be a list of licences that will be compatible with the GPLv3 (as of the currrent draft) that were not compatible with the GPLv2. As this is a MAJOR change to the GPL, an enumeration of these licences would be very helpful. It would also allow us to find cases were a licence tat was almost certainly intended to become compatible actually did not, and give the FSF an oppertunity to correct this. [[User:71.0.196.29|71.0.196.29]] 15:46, 19 January 2006 (EST)+
- +
- +
-Agreed, anyone should feel free to create this section. They could start with the information that Eben gave in his presentation at the opening of the conference. I'll get to making the section in the next couple of days if nobody else does, but anyone with the time should go ahead and do it now. We had planned on having a compatibility list here from the beginning but didn't make a placeholder for it. [[User:johns]]+
- +
-:An initial list is already available on [[Howto#Which licenses are compatible with GPLv3]]. If this is problematic, we can consider moving it. --[[User:brett|brett]] 17:43, 19 January 2006 (EST)+
- +
-== Server side applications ==+
- +
-New server side applications with a remote, mostly web interface are now appearing day after day and their number is bound to grow steadily over time. However, GPLv3 seems to neglect this. The only related clause is 7d) and it looks like added only to make GPLv3 compatible with the Affero GPL. +
- +
-Worse still, a requirement to "contain functioning factilities" to allow users to get source might be impossible to meet (for example in general purpose libraries or embedded devices' hardware) - so it'd make some formally GPLv3 compatible software unusable to other GPLv3 projects.+
- +
-To make things even worse, since general purpose libraries cannot include such an Affero-like clause for the above reasons, they may be used *without limitation* in defacto proprietary software that runs on the server side (yes, it's GPL, but since you're not receiving any object code, you have no right to request the source.)+
- +
-I think it should be solved by extending the rights given by the GPL to all users of the free software, not only to those people that happen to get some executable - and this should be the main change from GPLv2 to v3.+
- +
-:Thank you for your suggestions. I encourage you to please submit them to [http://gplv3.fsf.org/comments the comment system], where they can be reviewed by discussion committees and handled appropriately. --[[User:brett|brett]] 10:35, 29 January 2006 (EST)+
- +
-In fact, section 2 seems to almost explicitly allow such "defacto proprietary" software with "Propagation of covered works is permitted without limitation provided it does not enable parties other than you to make or receive copies." unless their specific license contains an Affero-like clause. --jsz 21:45, 22 February 2006 (CET)+
- +
-I agree with this section -- attention must be paid to this issue, and it will only continue to grow in importance with time. It's good that the gplv3 provides support for developers to add their own Affero-like clauses. +
- +
-However, I think it would be even better if the FSF were to produce a standard-GPL-with-Affero-style-clause that prohibited deploying a server running the licensed software without also making the source available. Even if all that was done was rename the Affero license to "Server-Side GPL", it would provide a common reference point, and prevent an inevitable soup of subtly-differing clauses all attempting to do the same thing. It would be awful if there was a profusion of open source web applications, each of which ostensibly was gplv3 but also had its own clauses that needed to be examined individually. The FSF needs to provide leadership on how to keep software free in a world of server-side applications. --[[User:breath|breath]] 19:32, 28 February 2006 (EST)+
- +
-== Test Cases ==+
- +
-I just added the link to [[Test_Cases]] back to the front page. Brett removed it earlier, and I added comments to the talk page explaining why I think it should be kept. I put the link back on this page in order to ping the people in charge, so we can talk about it. +
- +
---[[User:stefie10|stefie10]] 11:43, 30 January 2006 (EST)+
- +
-== A place for external links? (updated) ==+
- +
-Hi, [http://ciaran.compsoc.com ciaran o'riordan] here. I've made:+
-* [http://www.ifso.ie/projects/gplv3.html a webpage about GPLv3 for Irish Free Software Organisation]+
-* [http://ciaran.compsoc.com/2006-01-19-gplv3-belfast.html a webpage of the notes I used for a talk about GPLv3]+
-* [http://www.ifso.ie/documents/gplv3-launch-2006-01-16.html a transcript of the GPLv3 launch presentation]+
- +
-Should this wiki have a place for collecting links to such documents - which are about GPLv3 promotion and explanation, not about the GPLv3 itself - or is there a "no external links" policy or what? Thanks to anyone who can clear this up. [[User:ciaran|ciaran]] 15:17, 10 February 2006 (EST)+
- +
-:Ok, I've made a page for these: [[Reusable texts]]. Comments? [[User:ciaran|ciaran]] 11:02, 13 February 2006 (EST)+
- +
-That's good, Ciaran. I may want to transfer some of these links away from the wiki to the gplv3.fsf.org/av section, if that's alright with you. I'm thinking in particular the transcript. What do you think? --[[User:johns|johns]] 16:58, 24 February 2006 (EST)+
- +
-:Linking to the transcript from gplv3.fsf.org/av makes sense, and I'd be happy if FSF did. I think it would still be good though to leave a link to the transcript on the wiki. It shows an example of what sort of materials people can make and/or link to. [[User:ciaran|ciaran]] 21:45, 28 February 2006 (EST)+
- +
-Ok, I can agree that it serves some purpose by staying on the wiki as well. --[[User:johns|johns]] 17:24, 1 March 2006 (EST)+

Revision as of 02:39, 27 March 2006

two thumbs up!!!Oh, there is such a thing ! It is really too interesting. Heartily! I come to USA, welcome to come to USA to play, I will become your guide then 杭州网站建设 杭州网络公司 sony vaio sonystyle 国際電話のかけ方 学資保険 ソニー バイオ パソコン ソニースタイル cheap wow gold Marble fireplace surround Marble statue Marble bathtub Marble lions Sandstone tile Marble doorway Blue limestone tile Marble gazebo Marble pillar Cheap world of warcraft gold replica watch replica watch replica watch replica watch replica rolex replica rolex Powerleveling power leveling wow powerleveling wow power leveling World Of Warcraft powerleveling World Of Warcraft powerleveling world of warcraft power leveling aloe vera aloe vera Buy World of Warcraft gold Buy WoW gold Buy WoW gold Buy World of Warcraft gold Marble fireplace Marble columns Marble fountain Marble sculpture Marble sculpture IRON OXIDE IRON OXIDE paper box made in china china paper bag antistatic china paper box Marble bench Stone bathtub Stone flowerpot Carved fireplace rubber hose frp pipe,FRP RO Pressure Vessels magnesium oxide board PULTRUDED PROFILES sodium percarbonate Flex banner Industrial polyester yarn bamboo veneer bamboo veneer 云南旅游 云南旅游 云南旅游 云南旅游 投资 创业 银饰批发 mba 家居用品 隆胸 饰品|925银饰 家居用品 银饰 饰品 门禁 监控 翻译公司|翻译公司| 翻译公司 |翻译公司| 颜料 花店 中央空调 深圳鲜花 礼品 礼品公司 杭州网站建设 翻译公司 租车 上海租车 上海租车|汽车租赁 汽车租赁|上海汽车租赁 英语翻译 机票| 上海网站建设 毕业论文 ソニー バイオ パソコン ソニースタイル 国際電話のかけ方 ウォータースポーツ用品 エアーベッド エアーベッド