This website is an archive. It was used for drafting and public consultation on GPLv3 and version 3 of other GNU licenses which were published in 2007. For up to date information, see https://www.gnu.org/licenses/licenses.html. For more information about this archive, see https://www.fsf.org/licensing/gplv3-archive

From GPLv3 Wiki

Revision as of 16:55, 16 August 2006 Ownut (Talk | contribs) Ruminations about the completeness of Convey ← Previous diff		Current revision Ownut (Talk | contribs) cleanup
Line 1:		Line 1:
		+	I've been thinking about the words [[Propagat]]e and [[Convey]] and how they relate to Remote Access and Public Display.
-	I've been thinking about the word [[Convey]] and how it relates to [[Server Side]] issue and wondering how the CC licenses address this for public broadcast of audio or video.	+	For instance what happens when a GPL song is played on the radio or a movie is presented in a theatre? Are the consumers guaranteed access to the uncompressed source files?
-		+
-	For instance what happens when a GPL song is played on the radio or a movie is presented in a theatre?	+
	similar verbs: share, copy, show, give, share, help, transmit, teach, present, display, host, manage, guard, police, keep, supply, allow, access, communicate, transport, transfer, project, sell, give		similar verbs: share, copy, show, give, share, help, transmit, teach, present, display, host, manage, guard, police, keep, supply, allow, access, communicate, transport, transfer, project, sell, give
-	similar concern: [[http://radar.oreilly.com/archives/2006/08/open_source_licenses_are_obsol.html Open Source Licenses are Obsolete]]	+	Similar concerns:
		+
		+	* [[http://radar.oreilly.com/archives/2006/08/open_source_licenses_are_obsol.html Open Source Licenses are Obsolete]]
		+
		+	* What's wrong with this picture? Well, one thing is that one of the fundamental premises of open source is that the licenses are all conditioned on the act of software [[Distribut]]ion, and once you're no longer [[Distribut]]ing an application, none of the licenses mean squat. -- http://infoworld.com/article/03/07/03/HNoreilly_1.html
		+
		+
		+	Are we not users of software held closed by Amazon and Google?
		+
		+	How does telnet, VNC or FreeNX, Terminal Services, distributed computing (such as SETI et al) fit into this...
	-- Ownut		-- Ownut

---

Current revision

I've been thinking about the words Propagate and Convey and how they relate to Remote Access and Public Display.

For instance what happens when a GPL song is played on the radio or a movie is presented in a theatre? Are the consumers guaranteed access to the uncompressed source files?

similar verbs: share, copy, show, give, share, help, transmit, teach, present, display, host, manage, guard, police, keep, supply, allow, access, communicate, transport, transfer, project, sell, give

Similar concerns:

• [Open Source Licenses are Obsolete]

• What's wrong with this picture? Well, one thing is that one of the fundamental premises of open source is that the licenses are all conditioned on the act of software Distribution, and once you're no longer Distributing an application, none of the licenses mean squat. -- http://infoworld.com/article/03/07/03/HNoreilly_1.html

Are we not users of software held closed by Amazon and Google?

How does telnet, VNC or FreeNX, Terminal Services, distributed computing (such as SETI et al) fit into this...

-- Ownut